The Anatomy of Desperation: Why Hoby Milner Is Not the Answer You Think He Is
And so it happens again. The Chicago Cubs front office, led by Jed Hoyer, makes another move that leaves you scratching your head, wondering if they’re actually trying to win or just trying to look busy. The headline? A big, bold, yet ultimately hollow declaration that the team has agreed to sign Hoby Milner, a left-handed relief pitcher who, let’s face it, is closer to the end of his career than the beginning. He’s 34 years old, which in baseball years for a non-closer, might as well be 104. The official word on the street is that Milner “fills a key need for the bullpen.” A key need? More like a band-aid slapped on a gaping, arterial wound where a competitive pitching staff used to be. This isn’t a power move; it’s a desperate scramble for spare parts, a sign that the Ricketts family isn’t willing to open the checkbook wide enough to actually compete with the big boys in the National League.
But let’s not just call it cheap; let’s call it what it really is: a high-stakes gamble on a low-ceiling guy. The Cubs brass wants you to believe they found a diamond in the rough, a veteran who can stabilize things. The reality, however, looks a lot more like they picked up the last guy available on the bargain bin at closing time. Because when you’re talking about the Cubs bullpen, “key need” is a massive understatement. It’s not a need; it’s a black hole, a place where leads go to die. Every single time the Cubs get a decent start from one of their rotation guys—and let’s be honest, those starts are far too infrequent—you hold your breath when the ball gets handed over to the relief corps. The pressure is on, and the bullpen folds like a cheap lawn chair under pressure. So, what exactly is Hoby Milner bringing to this high-pressure situation, aside from a few extra miles on his arm?
Hoby Milner: Journeyman, Specialist, or Just Plain Tired?
Let’s talk about Milner’s history. This isn’t some hot prospect fresh out of Triple-A; this is a guy who has bounced around the league like a pinball since 2017, spending time with the Philadelphia Phillies, the Tampa Bay Rays, the Cleveland Guardians (back when they were still the Indians), and a few other stops in between. When a player has that many different uniforms hanging in his closet by age 34, it usually means one of two things: either he’s a highly sought-after specialist that teams trade for constantly, or he’s just good enough to be a marginal utility player who gets discarded as soon as something better comes along. And in Milner’s case, he hasn’t exactly been setting the world on fire with dominant performances. He’s a serviceable lefty, a guy you bring in to get one or two outs against a specific type of hitter, and then you pray the next guy in line can finish the job without imploding.
Now, I know what you’re thinking: “But a lefty specialist is exactly what the Cubs need!” The logic is sound, but let’s look deeper at the situation. A lefty specialist in 2024 is a different animal than it was ten years ago, thanks to the three-batter minimum rule. You can’t just bring Milner in to face one left-handed slugger and then immediately yank him for a righty. He has to stay in there for at least three batters, which means he’s probably going to have to face a right-handed hitter at some point. If his value is strictly limited to getting lefties out, and he can’t handle a right-handed bat, then this signing creates a new problem for the manager instead of solving the old one. It’s a risk. A big one. Because if Milner comes in and gives up a home run to a righty, or walks two batters and blows the save, then that “key need” just became a “key disaster.”
The Financial Tightness of the Cubs and the Desperation Factor
But the real story here isn’t Hoby Milner himself; it’s what his signing says about the Cubs’ financial philosophy. The Ricketts family has been absolutely notorious for their reluctance to spend big money on high-impact free agents. We saw it with the departure of key players during the last rebuild. We saw it when they passed on elite pitchers this offseason. Instead of going out and getting a top-tier, proven closer or a high-leverage reliever in the mold of a Josh Hader or a high-end setup man, they are once again looking for value. And value, when you’re talking about a 34-year-old journeyman, usually means low-risk, low-reward. The front office will spin this as shrewd business, a sign of finding ‘market inefficiencies.’ I call it being cheap. And cheap doesn’t win championships when you’re playing against teams that are willing to go all in.
The Cubs have a fan base starving for real contention. They want to see the team make a definitive statement. Instead, they get this. A minor signing. A depth move. A transaction that, if we’re being completely honest, probably wouldn’t even register in the sports news cycle of most major markets unless it was a slow news day. The fact that this is presented as a significant piece of the puzzle shows just how far the bar has dropped. The key need for the Cubs isn’t a single pitcher; it’s a new mindset from the top down. It’s a commitment to spending money on elite talent instead of trying to patch holes with guys who are just hoping to hold onto their jobs. Because when you’re a team that’s trying to get back to the top of the division, a guy who fills a “key need” by simply existing isn’t going to be enough.
Will Milner Be a Diamond in the Rough or a Bust? A Tabloid Prognosis
So, where does this leave us? Is there any chance this move actually pays off? Maybe. In baseball, sometimes you catch lightning in a bottle. Maybe Milner found something in his mechanics over the winter. Maybe he’s got one last great season left in him before he hangs up his cleats. But the odds are stacked against him. He’s coming into a high-pressure environment where the fans are demanding results immediately. He’s joining a bullpen that’s already been shaky, meaning a single bad outing will put him under the microscope in a way that he probably hasn’t experienced in years. The pressure to perform for a high-leverage relief role on a contending team—or a team *pretending* to contend—is immense, and Milner has typically been a middle-to-low-leverage guy in his career. The expectation for him to suddenly become a high-impact player is unrealistic.
But let’s think about the alternative. What if this move is actually a stroke of genius by Jed Hoyer? What if Milner is exactly what he needs? The Cubs’ pitching situation has been a hot mess for a long time. The rotation has been inconsistent, and the bullpen has been forced to carry an impossible load. Adding a veteran lefty who can eat innings and occasionally get a tough out against a good left-handed hitter could be exactly what the doctor ordered, especially if the cost is minimal. But again, this relies on a massive dose of optimism. The more likely scenario is that Milner provides temporary relief, maybe for a month or two, before the wear and tear of a full season catches up with him. He’ll either be injured by the All-Star break or struggling with command issues. That’s just the reality of a 34-year-old journeyman. The Cubs front office is hoping for a miracle, but miracles don’t happen every day in baseball, especially when you’re not willing to pay for them. It’s a cheap attempt to appease the crowd, and we’ll see exactly how long that lasts when the season starts to heat up.
Photo by MikeGoad on Pixabay.