College Football Playoff System is a House of Cards

December 6, 2025

The Facade is Cracking

They sold you a lie. Let’s just start there. They sold everyone a bill of goods at the start of the season, showing us those shiny preseason polls with all the familiar names locked in at the top, a nice, neat little hierarchy to keep the casuals placated and the TV money flowing without interruption. It was a comfortable illusion. A sedative. But it’s all falling apart right now, in real-time, and if you aren’t panicking, you are simply not paying attention to the disaster unfolding before our very eyes. This isn’t football. It’s a controlled demolition where someone has lost the detonator.

Remember August? It feels like a decade ago. Three of the top four teams from that farcical AP Poll stumbled out of the gate, looking less like titans and more like toddlers learning to walk. It was a joke. Only one of them even managed to crawl back into relevance, which should tell you everything you need to know about the so-called experts and the system they prop up (a system built on reputation, not reality). Nine of the top fifteen teams looked like they were playing with a deflated ball for the first month. This entire season has been built on a foundation of quicksand, and now, with championship weekend upon us, the whole corrupt edifice is about to get swallowed whole. Don’t look away.

The Great Unraveling

This isn’t just a few upsets. No, this is systemic failure. The transfer portal and NIL money (let’s just call it what it is: legal pay-for-play) have completely destabilized the sport, turning it into a free-for-all where loyalty is dead and rosters are as stable as a Jenga tower in an earthquake. The old guard, the blue bloods who have run this sport for a century, are losing their grip. They thought they could control the chaos they created, that they could keep the money and power concentrated in the same two conferences. But the monster is off the leash. What we’re seeing this weekend isn’t a celebration of champions. It’s a desperate, last-gasp attempt to force the narrative back into the bottle before an undefeated team from the wrong side of the tracks (God forbid) crashes their exclusive party and exposes the whole thing as the rigged game it truly is. They are terrified. You can feel it. The press releases are getting more defensive, the talking heads are shouting louder. It’s the sound of an empire crumbling.

A Powder Keg Disguised as Championship Saturday

Forget the pageantry. Forget the marching bands and the corporate-sponsored trophies. This Saturday is not a series of football games; it is a minefield. Every single matchup is a potential trigger for total, unadulterated chaos that could render the College Football Playoff committee’s job not just difficult, but utterly impossible (and expose their utter incompetence in the process). They have no idea what to do if the wrong teams win. None. They will be trapped, live on national television, forced to justify a set of rankings that will have been blown to smithereens.

The SEC: A Battle of Oblivion

Down in Atlanta, you have the SEC Championship. Georgia versus Alabama. It’s being billed as a clash of titans, the master versus the apprentice, the unstoppable dynasty against the aging king. But that’s the sanitized TV version. What this really is? It’s a cage match. Georgia, the two-time defending champ, the seemingly invincible juggernaut, has looked suspiciously mortal at times this season. They’re not the same monster they were. They’re beatable. And on the other side, you have Nick Saban. A cornered Nick Saban, which is the most dangerous creature in the known universe. He has a team that has no business being here, a team that almost lost to an FCS school and a team from the cow pastures of Auburn, and yet, here they are. They are playing with house money and a vendetta. If Alabama wins this game, the entire playoff bracket explodes. It detonates. Do you leave out a one-loss SEC champion Alabama? Do you dare leave out a Georgia team whose only loss was to that champion on a neutral field? The committee will have to pick its poison, and in doing so, will invalidate the entire regular season for one half of the country. It’s a no-win scenario. It is a catastrophe by design. And it’s beautiful.

The Big Ten: The Illusion of Clarity

Then you look at the Big Ten Championship. Ohio State and Indiana. On paper, it looks straightforward. A blue-blood powerhouse against a scrappy underdog. But nothing is straightforward anymore! Ohio State, with their roster of five-star recruits and their pristine record, is carrying the weight of a conference that has felt perpetually second-best to the SEC. A loss here wouldn’t just be an upset; it would be a humiliation of epic proportions, a confirmation of every negative stereotype about them being soft and unable to win the big one. It would knock them out of the playoff picture instantly and violently. For Indiana, this is their shot at immortality, a chance to burn the whole established order to the ground. An Indiana win creates a vacuum. A one-loss Big Ten champion would have a claim, but would the committee respect it? Or would they use it as an excuse to slot in a one-loss Texas or a one-loss Oregon, igniting a firestorm of controversy that would rage for months? The ‘simple’ game is anything but. It’s another tripwire. They are everywhere. There is no safe path. There is only carnage.

The System is a Lie and the Future is Bleak

The worst part of all this is the lie they’ll tell you on Sunday. The lie that the four teams selected by the committee are the ‘best’ or the most ‘deserving.’ It is an absolute fiction. The College Football Playoff committee is not a panel of objective experts. It is a boardroom of television executives, conference commissioners, and athletic directors whose sole job is to protect the financial interests of the sport’s ruling class. Their decisions are not based on data or on-field performance; they are based on brand names, TV ratings, and backroom deals. They are creating a television show, not crowning a legitimate champion. This weekend’s chaos will simply force them to show their hand. They will be forced to pick and choose between equally flawed, equally deserving (or undeserving) teams, and their arbitrary choice will expose the selection process for the sham that it is.

The 12-Team ‘Solution’ is an Even Bigger Problem

And don’t you dare fall for their next trick. Don’t let them sell you the 12-team playoff as the cure for all this. It’s not. The 12-team playoff is just a bigger lie. It’s a cash grab designed to devalue the regular season even further, turning epic November showdowns into meaningless seeding games. It ensures the same big-brand teams get multiple bites at the apple, guaranteeing a spot for a three-loss Alabama or Ohio State while telling the smaller conference champions to be happy with their first-round exit and their pat on the head. It solves nothing. It just makes the problem bigger and the corruption more diffuse. It’s a bigger trough for the same pigs. Instead of arguing about team number four versus team number five, we’ll be screaming about why team twelve got in over team thirteen. It’s the same broken logic, just expanded to a comical degree. It’s a guarantee of mediocrity in the postseason. This weekend, this beautiful, horrifying, chaotic weekend, might be the last time any of this feels like it truly matters. We are on the precipice. And the fall is going to be a long one. Get ready.

College Football Playoff System is a House of Cards

Leave a Comment